Skip to main content

Earnings Season: A Playground for Volatility Traders

🌟 The Super Bowl of Volatility Trading​

Four times a year, the market transforms. The quiet, orderly procession of daily price movements gives way to a period of intense speculation, heightened emotion, and explosive volatility. This is earnings season, and for the volatility trader, it's the Super Bowl. It's a time when the strategies we've discussed in this chapter are put to the ultimate test.

Earnings announcements are the single most significant, regularly scheduled catalysts for individual stock price movement. The uncertainty leading up to a report and the market's reaction after it create a unique and challenging environment. This article will guide you through the dynamics of earnings season, with a special focus on the predictable patterns of implied volatility and how to position yourself to profit from them.

The Earnings Cycle: A Predictable Pattern of Fear and Greed​

The lifecycle of an earnings trade follows a predictable pattern, driven by the ebb and flow of uncertainty.

  1. The Run-Up (Pre-Earnings): In the weeks and days leading up to an earnings announcement, uncertainty is at its peak. Will the company beat expectations? Will they raise guidance? This uncertainty causes traders to bid up the price of options, leading to a significant rise in implied volatility (IV).
  2. The Announcement: The company releases its earnings report. The market reacts instantly, and the stock price often makes a large move (up or down).
  3. The Aftermath (Post-Earnings): Once the news is out, the uncertainty evaporates. Regardless of the stock's price move, one thing is almost certain: implied volatility will collapse. This phenomenon is known as IV crush.

Understanding this cycle is the key to successfully trading earnings.

The IV Crush: The Option Buyer's Nightmare​

The IV crush is the most important concept to understand when trading earnings. It's a powerful force that can turn a seemingly winning trade into a loser.

Imagine you buy a straddle on a stock before its earnings report, betting on a large move. The company reports fantastic earnings, and the stock gaps up 10%. You were right about the direction and the magnitude of the move! But when you go to sell your straddle, you find that it's actually lost value. How is this possible?

The answer is IV crush. The pre-earnings spike in IV made the options you bought very expensive. After the announcement, the IV collapsed, and the value of your options plummeted, more than offsetting the profit from the stock's price move.

This is why simply buying a straddle or strangle before earnings is often a losing proposition. You are not just betting on the stock's direction; you are betting that the move will be larger than what the inflated options prices are already implying.

Selling Premium: The Professional's Approach​

If buying options before earnings is so difficult, what's the alternative? The answer is to be a seller of premium. By selling options when IV is high, you put the odds in your favor. You are taking the other side of the trade, selling the expensive "lottery tickets" to the speculators.

The goal is to profit from the predictable collapse in IV after the earnings announcement. This is a statistical and probabilistic approach to trading. You are not trying to predict the direction of the stock; you are simply betting that the market's fear is overblown.

Popular Earnings Strategies:

  • Short Straddle/Strangle: These are the most direct ways to sell premium, but they come with unlimited risk. A larger-than-expected move can lead to catastrophic losses. These should only be used by experienced traders with a high risk tolerance.
  • Iron Condor: This is the preferred strategy for many earnings traders. It allows you to sell premium with a defined-risk structure. By selling an iron condor, you are betting that the stock will stay within a certain range, and you are protected if the move is larger than expected. The width of your strikes should be chosen based on the expected move.
  • Iron Butterfly: A more aggressive version of the iron condor, the iron butterfly offers a higher potential reward but has a narrower profit range. This is a good choice if you believe the stock will have a muted reaction to the earnings report.

A Word of Caution​

While earnings season can be a profitable time for volatility traders, it's also a time of heightened risk. Here are a few things to keep in mind:

  • Liquidity: In the moments after an earnings release, liquidity can dry up, leading to wide bid-ask spreads. This can make it difficult to exit your position at a favorable price.
  • Gaps: Stocks can make massive moves, or "gap," up or down after an earnings announcement. These moves can be much larger than the expected move, and they can blow through the wings of your iron condor or butterfly, resulting in a maximum loss.
  • Binary Risk: An earnings announcement is a binary event. The outcome is unpredictable, and the market's reaction can be even more so. Never risk more on a single earnings trade than you are comfortable losing.

The Pre-Earnings Play: Trading the IV Run-Up​

An alternative to holding a position through the earnings announcement is to trade the run-up in IV itself.

  • The Strategy: Buy a straddle or strangle 1-2 weeks before the earnings announcement.
  • The Goal: Profit from the rise in implied volatility as the earnings date approaches.
  • The Exit: Sell the position the day before the earnings announcement, before the IV crush.

This strategy allows you to profit from the predictable pre-earnings IV expansion without taking on the risk of the earnings announcement itself.

Analyzing the Expected Move​

Before placing an earnings trade, it's crucial to analyze the "expected move." This is the amount that the options market is pricing in for the stock's post-earnings move. You can find this information on most trading platforms, or you can estimate it by looking at the price of an at-the-money straddle.

By comparing the expected move to the stock's historical average earnings move, you can get a sense of whether the market is overpricing or underpricing the potential for volatility.

  • If the expected move is much higher than the historical average: This might be a good opportunity to sell premium (e.g., an iron condor).
  • If the expected move is much lower than the historical average: This might be a rare opportunity to buy premium (e.g., a long straddle).

💡 Conclusion: A Game of Probabilities, Not Predictions​

Trading earnings is not about predicting the future. It's about understanding the predictable patterns of volatility and structuring trades that put the probabilities in your favor. By selling expensive options and buying cheap ones, and by always managing your risk, you can turn the uncertainty of earnings season into a consistent source of profit. It is a quarterly opportunity to apply your knowledge of volatility in a real-world, high-stakes environment.

Here’s what to remember:

  • IV Crush is the Dominant Force: The post-earnings collapse in implied volatility is the most important factor to consider. It is the primary reason why selling premium is often the more profitable approach.
  • Be a Seller, Not a Buyer: In most cases, it's more profitable to be a seller of premium around earnings than a buyer. The market tends to overprice the potential for a move, and you can profit from this inefficiency.
  • Defined-Risk is Your Friend: Strategies like the iron condor allow you to trade earnings with a defined risk profile. This is crucial, as earnings moves can be much larger than expected.
  • Analyze the Expected Move: Don't trade in a vacuum. Understand what the market is pricing in before you place your bet. This will help you determine if there is an edge to be had.
  • Don't Be Afraid to Sit It Out: If you don't have a clear edge, there's no shame in sitting out an earnings announcement. There will always be another opportunity.

Challenge Yourself: Pick a stock with an upcoming earnings report. Find the expected move priced in by the options market. Then, look at the stock's average earnings move over the past 4-8 quarters. Is the expected move higher or lower than the average? Based on this, would you be more inclined to buy or sell volatility? Now, design a specific trade (e.g., an iron condor with 15-delta short strikes) that you would place based on your analysis.

➡️ What's Next?​

We've now covered the theory and practice of trading volatility during earnings season. In the next article, "Case Study: A Successful Volatility Trade Around a News Event", we'll put it all together and walk through a real-world example of a successful earnings trade.

📚 Glossary & Further Reading​

Glossary:

  • Earnings Season: The period during which a large number of publicly traded companies release their quarterly earnings reports.
  • IV Crush: The rapid decrease in the implied volatility of an option's price after a significant event, such as an earnings report, has passed.
  • Expected Move: The amount a stock is expected to move up or down from its current price, as derived from current options prices.

Further Reading: