Skip to main content
Stock Market

Trading Earnings (With Caveats)

Pomegra Learn

Trading Earnings (With Caveats)

Some of the most exciting trading opportunities appear around earnings announcements, when expected volatility reaches its peak and stocks move dramatically. The temptation to trade earnings—to buy before the announcement if you think the company will beat, or short it if you think it will miss—is strong. But the sobering truth is that most retail traders and even many professionals lose money on earnings trades. Understanding why is critical before risking capital around earnings announcements.

The primary reason earnings trading is difficult is that the market is efficient. By the time earnings are announced, most of the information that traders can access is already reflected in the stock price. A company that everyone thinks will beat earnings likely already has that expectation built into the stock price, which means beating still might not push the stock higher if the beat is small. Professional traders often know management teams, have spoken with customers or suppliers, and have sophisticated models that give them real information advantages. Retail traders, by contrast, have the same analyst consensus and public information that's already baked into the price.

The second reason earnings trading is difficult is volatility. Right before earnings, implied volatility is at its highest—options are expensive, and the bid-ask spreads on stock trades can be wide. An options trader who buys a straddle right before earnings is paying the highest possible price for volatility, which means they need the stock to move significantly just to break even. After earnings are announced and volatility collapses, the value of the straddle falls even if the stock has moved, because the volatility component was worth money and now isn't.

The third reason is uncertainty about where expectations actually are. Even with the consensus estimate, traders don't always know what the whisper number is, what management's true guidance is, or what the market will focus on in the earnings release. A company that beats EPS but misses on forward guidance often see its stock fall sharply after an initial rally, leaving traders who bought on the beat confused about why the stock is declining.

Viable Earnings Trading Approaches​

That said, some earnings trading can be profitable with the right approach. Event-driven traders with genuine information advantages—perhaps they've spoken with suppliers or customers—can profit if they have real information the market doesn't. Traders who specialize in a particular sector and understand sector dynamics deeply might have edges that others don't. And traders who use disciplined, mechanical approaches to earnings trading—placing stops and limits before earnings, not deviating from a plan, and accepting small losses—can improve their odds.

The most important caveat is position sizing. Many retail traders bet too much capital on a single earnings announcement, meaning one wrong call can wipe out months of gains. Professional traders typically risk no more than 1% of their account on any single trade, and even less on high-volatility events like earnings. Risking appropriate position sizes means you can afford to be wrong several times in a row without devastating your account.

Articles in this chapter​