Skip to main content

Learning to Observe Without Forecasting

🌟 The Investor's Most Powerful, and Deeply Unnatural, Skill​

Welcome to a new chapter in your investing journey, and a new way of thinking. In our last chapter, we trained our eyes to see the market in our everyday lives. Now, we turn our attention to the market itself. But we're going to approach it in a way that feels deeply unnatural to most people. Our goal is not to predict the future. It is to see the present with absolute, unbiased clarity. The human brain is a prediction machine. From anticipating the path of a predator on the savanna to guessing the end of a movie, we are wired to constantly try and figure out what will happen next. This powerful instinct, while essential for survival, is one of the single greatest liabilities for a long-term investor. This article will teach you the critical, challenging, and deeply unnatural skill of learning to observe without forecasting.

Why Your Brain is a Terrible Stock Market Forecaster​

Our brains are riddled with deep-seated psychological biases that make us constitutionally terrible at predicting the future, especially in a complex, adaptive system like the stock market.

  • Overconfidence Bias: We systematically and dramatically overestimate our ability to predict future events. We see a stock go up and our brain whispers, "I knew it was going to do that." This illusion of knowledge and control leads to excessive risk-taking, concentrated portfolios, and a failure to appreciate the role of luck.
  • Recency Bias: We give far too much emotional and analytical weight to recent events. If the market has been soaring for the last year, our brains naturally extrapolate that trend into the future, ignoring decades of data showing that bull markets are inevitably followed by bear markets.
  • Confirmation Bias: We are not neutral seekers of truth; we are validation-seeking machines. We actively seek out information and opinions that confirm our existing beliefs and instinctively ignore or discredit information that contradicts them. If you believe a stock is a "winner," you will find all the reasons it's a winner and dismiss any and all warning signs as irrelevant "noise."
  • The Narrative Fallacy: We are wired to love stories. We prefer a simple, compelling narrative ("This company is the next Tesla!") over a complex and uncertain reality. This makes us susceptible to hype and causes us to build our investment cases on stories rather than on observable facts.

These biases create a powerful and toxic cocktail of flawed thinking that leads investors to make confident predictions that are, more often than not, completely wrong. The entire financial media industry is built to feed this addiction to forecasting, but it is a game you are statistically destined to lose.

The Art of Observation: Seeing What Is, Not What You Hope For​

If we must accept that we cannot predict the future, what can we do? We can dedicate ourselves to the rigorous and disciplined art of observation. Observation is not a passive act of simply looking at a stock chart. It is an active, analytical, forensic process of gathering information to understand the current state of a business and the market with as much clarity as possible.

Forecasting is about guessing the future. Observation is about understanding the present reality.

Forecasting (The Gambler's Mindset)Observation (The Detective's Mindset)
"I predict this stock will go to $200 by December.""I observe that this company is steadily gaining market share from its primary competitor."
"The market is definitely going to crash next month.""I observe that investor sentiment, according to the AAII survey, is becoming extremely fearful."
"This is the next Amazon! It's a ten-bagger for sure.""I observe that this company has a strong balance sheet with very little debt and high profit margins."
The Goal: Be right about the future.The Goal: Be accurate and unbiased about the present.

The "Scuttlebutt" Method: Your Observational Superpower​

The legendary growth investor Philip Fisher pioneered a powerful technique for observation that he called the "scuttlebutt" method. The term comes from the nautical word for a ship's water cask, where sailors would gather to drink and exchange gossip. Fisher's profound insight was that you can learn far more about a company's true operational reality by talking to the people in its ecosystem than you can from any spreadsheet or financial report.

The scuttlebutt method is about asking probing questions to build a mosaic of the present reality:

  • Talk to Customers: Are they happy? Are they loyal? What do they wish was better about the product? Why did they choose it over a competitor?
  • Talk to Suppliers: Are they being paid on time? Are they excited about the company's future orders, or are they seeing a slowdown? Do they respect the company's management?
  • Talk to Employees (especially former ones): What is the company culture really like? Is management respected and trusted? Is morale high or low? (Glassdoor is a modern scuttlebutt tool).
  • Talk to Competitors: What are they most worried about? What are this company's greatest, most defensible strengths and its most glaring weaknesses?

This is true detective work. You are gathering clues and evidence, not staring into a crystal ball.

From Observation to Insight: Connecting the Clues​

The goal of observation is not just to collect a list of disconnected facts, but to synthesize those facts into a cohesive insight. An insight is a deep, holistic understanding of a company's current competitive position and its potential trajectory based on current evidence.

  • Observation: "I visited five of the company's retail stores, and they were all clean, well-stocked, and staffed with happy, genuinely helpful employees."

  • Insight: "This company has a strong and healthy corporate culture focused on operational excellence. This is likely a durable competitive advantage that financial statements cannot show."

  • Observation: "I spoke to three of the company's long-time customers, and they all complained that the new software update is confusing and that customer service has been slow to respond."

  • Insight: "The company may be facing internal execution problems or is at risk of losing its reputation for quality, which could open the door for a competitor."

Notice that these insights are not predictions. They are assessments of the present reality, based on a collection of observable evidence.

How to Practice the Discipline of Observational Investing​

  1. Start an Investment Journal (for Observations Only): Do not use it to write down predictions. Use it to write down facts and observations. "Today I noticed..." "I learned that..." "I read that the company is closing three factories..."
  2. Read for Clues, Not for Conclusions: When you read an earnings report or a news article, don't look for a forecast or a price target. Look for clues about the present state of the business. Is debt going up or down? Are profit margins expanding or contracting? Is inventory growing faster than sales?
  3. Reframe Your Questions from "What If?" to "What Is?": Every time you feel the powerful urge to make a prediction ("What if this company's stock doubles?"), stop yourself. Reframe the question into an observational one ("What is the evidence that this company is successfully growing its customer base today?").
  4. Embrace the Three Most Powerful Words: "I Don't Know": The most intelligent and honest words an investor can say when asked about the future of the market or a stock are "I don't know." Admitting that you cannot predict the future frees up immense mental energy to focus on what you can know: the reality of the business today.

💡 Conclusion: The Overwhelming Power of the Present Moment​

The desire to predict the future is deeply human, but in the world of investing, it is a siren song that leads countless investors to financial ruin. The greatest investors of all time are not fortune-tellers; they are master observers and learning machines. They have trained themselves to fight their own natural biases and to see the world as it is, not as they wish or fear it to be. By consciously shifting your focus from forecasting to observation, you move from the realm of speculation and gambling to the realm of disciplined analysis. You will make fewer, better, and more rational decisions, and you will be insulated from the emotional rollercoaster of the market's noisy, and usually wrong, daily predictions.

Here’s what to remember:

  • Your Brain is a Flawed Forecasting Machine: Be constantly aware of your innate biases like overconfidence, recency bias, and the powerful pull of a good story.
  • Observation is an Active, Not a Passive, Skill: It's about disciplined, evidence-based detective work aimed at building a clear picture of the present reality.
  • Focus on "What Is," Not "What If": Replace speculative, predictive questions with factual, observational ones.
  • Embrace Intellectual Humility: The market is a complex, adaptive system. Acknowledge that you cannot predict its short-term movements, and you will be liberated.

Challenge Yourself: Pick one stock you own or are interested in. For one full week, your challenge is to follow the news and information about that company, but with a strict rule: you are not allowed to read any article, analyst report, or social media post that contains a price target or a future prediction (e.g., "Analyst says stock will hit $X"). You can only consume information that describes the current state of the business—a new product launch, a factory opening, a management change, a customer review. See how this simple filter changes your understanding of and feel for the company.

➡️ What's Next?​

You've now learned the foundational principle of this chapter: observe, don't predict. In our next article, "Understanding Market Cycles," we'll apply this powerful observational skill to the market itself. We'll learn how to recognize the four key stages of a market cycle, not to predict the exact top or bottom, but to understand the current psychological climate of the market and to act with rationality and wisdom.

📚 Glossary & Further Reading​

Glossary:

  • Forecasting: The act of predicting future events or conditions, often using historical data and statistical models.
  • Observation: The act of noticing or perceiving things and gathering information about the present state of affairs.
  • Psychological Bias: A systematic pattern of deviation from norm or rationality in judgment, whereby inferences about other people and situations may be drawn in an illogical fashion.
  • Scuttlebutt Method: An investment research technique, popularized by Philip Fisher, that involves gathering information from a wide range of informal sources within a company's ecosystem, such as customers, suppliers, and competitors.

Further Reading: