Skip to main content

Market makers and liquidity

A market maker is a trader or firm that stands ready to buy or sell a security at any time, profiting from the spread—the difference between the price at which they buy and the price at which they sell. Market makers are the mechanism through which exchanges provide continuous liquidity, ensuring that orders can be filled immediately rather than waiting for a natural buyer or seller to appear. Without market makers, every stock transaction would require finding an exact counterparty willing to trade at the exact price—a process that could take hours or never happen at all. Market makers solve this matching problem by taking the other side of trades, holding inventory, and managing the risk of those positions.

The economics of market making have evolved dramatically with electronic trading and regulation. Traditional market makers on the NYSE trading floor earned their profits through spreads and volume. Modern market makers operate electronically and must compete fiercely on speed and price. Citadel Securities, Virtu Financial, Two Sigma, and other mega-scale market makers now dominate the US equity market, executing a significant percentage of retail trades and handling enormous order flow. Designated market makers—specialists assigned to specific stocks on major exchanges—maintain a different role: they have market-making obligations but also serve regulatory functions like managing volatility and ensuring fair opening and closing prices.

The market for liquidity itself has become a battleground. Exchanges offer fees and incentives to attract market makers. Brokers route order flow to market makers who provide execution rebates or superior prices. Investors benefit from tighter spreads and faster execution than would exist if market makers didn't exist, but they also bear the risk that market makers might withdraw liquidity during stress periods. The tension between market makers' profit incentives and the public's need for reliable liquidity defines much of modern market regulation. Understanding market makers illuminates why spreads widen during volatility, why some stocks are more liquid than others, and how much of the modern market is actually driven by firms making their money from tiny fractions of pennies on billions of shares.

Articles in this chapter​