Skip to main content

Notes to financial statements

The numbers on the three financial statements are the summary. The notes are the confession. In the notes, management explains its accounting choices, discloses the details that do not fit neatly into the standardized line items, reveals future obligations, describes contingent liabilities, and breaks down aggregated numbers into their components.

Most investors ignore the notes. They read the summary numbers and make their decisions. This is a mistake. The notes often contain information that changes the interpretation of the financial statements entirely. A company might show a large profit on the income statement, but the notes might reveal that most of that profit came from a one-time gain that will not recur. A company might show strong cash flow from operations, but the notes might reveal that a large customer has already announced it is leaving, which will reduce future revenue. A company might show manageable debt on the balance sheet, but the notes might reveal that much of that debt matures in the next eighteen months and must be refinanced. The notes are where the messiness of reality lives.

Accounting policies reveal flexibility​

Every financial statement begins with a section on "Significant Accounting Policies" that describes how the company has chosen to apply the accounting standards. These choices are critical because they directly affect reported profits and asset values.

Consider revenue recognition. The policy note might explain that the company recognizes revenue when goods are shipped to the customer, when the customer receives the goods, or when the customer is invoiced. For a global company with long shipping times, this choice can shift revenue between quarters or years. Or consider the policy on warranty reserves—the company might estimate that it will need to spend money fixing products under warranty and record that estimate as a liability today, or it might wait until warranty claims actually arrive. The policy note tells you which approach the company uses, which affects how much profit is recognized today versus deferred to the future.

Depreciation policy is another key one. A company might depreciate a piece of equipment over five years or over twenty years. Both are "reasonable" under accounting standards, but the choice directly affects how much depreciation expense is recorded each year, which directly affects net income. A company that depreciates assets very slowly will report higher profits than a company that depreciates them quickly, even if they are identical companies. The policy note reveals this choice, and comparing it to competitors reveals whether the company is being aggressive or conservative.

Segment reporting breaks down the aggregate​

Most companies operate multiple business segments. A consumer products company might have home care, personal care, and foods divisions. A technology company might have cloud infrastructure, software, and advertising segments. The consolidated financial statements show the total revenue and profit across all segments, but that totals hides important information.

The segment reporting notes break down revenue, profit, assets, and sometimes cash flow by segment. This lets an investor see which parts of the business are growing and which are declining, which are profitable and which are losing money. A company might show flat overall revenue growth, but the segment notes might reveal that the profitable core business is growing ten percent while the legacy business is declining twenty percent. This is critical information for understanding whether the company's future looks bright or dim.

Segment reporting also reveals the financial impact of the company's portfolio. If one segment is highly profitable and others are barely breaking even, the company's overall profitability depends critically on the health of that one segment. If a large customer is concentrated in one segment, the segment notes might be where that is disclosed. An investor can use segment reporting to build a view of what the company might be worth if its segments were separated or sold.

Contingent liabilities can hide future losses​

A contingent liability is an obligation that might occur, depending on future events. The most common examples are legal disputes, regulatory investigations, and warranty obligations. These do not always appear as liabilities on the balance sheet; instead, they are described in the notes.

A company might disclose that it is being sued in a class-action lawsuit. The company has not yet lost the lawsuit, so it does not record a loss on the income statement or a liability on the balance sheet. But the notes describe the lawsuit and provide management's estimate of the likely outcome. A company might estimate that it will probably lose the lawsuit and owe $500 million in damages. This might be disclosed in a note, but not recorded in the financial statements until the loss is probable and measurable—which might be years away.

For an investor, reading the contingent liability notes is essential because it reveals obligations that are not yet in the numbers. A company might appear to have a fortress balance sheet, but the notes might reveal a $2 billion lawsuit that management believes it will lose. Similarly, a company might have a pending acquisition that will require it to assume large liabilities. These future obligations should affect your investment decision even if they are not yet reflected in the current financial statements.

Related-party transactions are deals between the company and its founders, executives, major shareholders, or affiliated companies. These transactions are inherently suspect because the parties cannot negotiate at arm's length; one party can exert control or influence over the other.

A company might buy inventory from a supplier owned by the CEO. Is the price fair? Or is the company overpaying to benefit the CEO's supplier business? The company might pay high rent to a building owned by a board member. Is the rent market rate? Or is the company overpaying? These are not necessarily wrong—sometimes there are legitimate reasons for related-party transactions. But they deserve scrutiny. The notes disclose related-party transactions and provide details of the terms. An investor should read these carefully and ask whether the terms are favorable to the company or favorable to the related party.

Future obligations and debt maturity​

The notes contain tables describing the maturity of debt and other future obligations. A company might have $100 million in total debt, but the notes should break down how much is due in each of the next five years. This reveals whether the company has a wall of refinancing coming due that might force it to raise capital at unfavorable terms, or whether the debt is spread evenly over time.

Similarly, the notes describe future operating lease obligations (for a company with significant leases), pension obligations (if the company has a defined-benefit pension plan), and contingent consideration from acquisitions. These all represent cash that will flow out in the future, even if not yet recorded as liabilities. An investor assessing free cash flow needs to account for these future obligations.

Articles in this chapter​