Deferred Tax Asset vs Deferred Tax Liability

A deferred tax asset or deferred tax liability arises when a company’s book income (what it reports to investors) differs from its taxable income (what it reports to tax authorities) in a way that will eventually reverse. Deferred tax assets represent future tax reductions; deferred tax liabilities represent future tax obligations.

What Creates a Deferred Tax Balance

Companies keep two sets of financial records: one for investors (using generally-accepted-accounting-principles) and one for the IRS (using the tax code). The rules differ. A company might depreciate an asset over 5 years under GAAP but 3 years under tax law. In year one, taxable income is lower than book income, so taxes owed are lower than the book tax expense. That gap is a deferred tax liability—the company will pay more tax in the future when the asset is fully written down under both rules.

Conversely, if a company takes a tax deduction now that it cannot claim under GAAP until later, book income is lower but taxable income is higher. It pays more tax today than its book expense suggests it “should.” The overpayment is a deferred tax asset—the company will claim a matching deduction under GAAP in a future year and recover that benefit.

Common Sources of Deferred Tax Assets

A deferred tax asset appears when a company has already borne an economic cost or loss that the tax code has not yet allowed it to deduct, or when it will receive a deduction in the future that it has not yet claimed.

Net operating losses. If a company loses money in year one, it cannot use that loss to offset tax in that year (because taxable income is already negative). Instead, the loss carries forward. The value of that future deduction is a deferred tax asset. If the company is profitable in year two, it can use the carryforward to reduce year-two taxes.

Warranty and restructuring reserves. A company accrues a warranty reserve under GAAP when it sells a product, because it expects to honor claims. The tax code allows a deduction only when the warranty is actually paid. Until payment, the difference is a deferred tax asset.

Deductible temporary differences. A company might claim a tax depreciation or amortization deduction that exceeds its book depreciation, or take a tax credit that reduces its book tax expense. The temporary advantage creates a deferred tax asset.

Common Sources of Deferred Tax Liabilities

A deferred tax liability appears when a company has claimed a tax benefit earlier than GAAP allows, or will claim deductions in the future that reduce taxable income below book income.

Accelerated depreciation. The most common example. A company depreciates an asset over 7 years under GAAP but 5 years under tax law. In years 1–5, depreciation is higher for tax purposes, so taxable income is lower and taxes are lower. In years 6–7, tax depreciation is zero but book depreciation continues, so taxable income is higher and taxes are higher. The company is deferring taxes forward—a deferred tax liability.

Installment sales. A company sells equipment for a long-term installment note. Under GAAP, it recognizes the full gain immediately. Under the tax code, it recognizes gain only as it collects cash. Taxable income lags book income, creating a deferred tax liability.

Timing of revenue recognition. A company might recognize revenue under GAAP when a contract is signed, but under tax law only when cash is received. The gap creates a deferred tax liability that reverses as cash arrives.

When Deferred Tax Assets Face Impairment

A deferred tax asset is only valuable if the company has future taxable income to offset. If a company carries a large net operating loss carryforward but expects to remain unprofitable, the deferred tax asset may never be used. Generally-accepted-accounting-principles requires management to assess whether the deferred tax asset is “more likely than not” to be realized. If the company is not profitable enough, the asset is written down—a charge called a valuation allowance.

A large valuation allowance signals that creditors and investors should doubt whether the company will recover its losses before they expire. Under current law, net operating losses carry forward indefinitely, but their use is limited if there is a major change in ownership (Section 382 limitation).

How Deferred Taxes Affect Cash Flow and Reporting

Deferred taxes can create a gap between reported earnings and actual cash taxes paid. If a company has a large deferred tax liability, it is paying less tax today than its book expense suggests—a benefit to cash flow now, but an obligation later. Conversely, a company with a large deferred tax asset is deferring cash tax benefits into the future.

The cash-flow-statement captures this distinction. The operating section begins with net income (book earnings) and then adjusts for the deferred tax expense—the non-cash charge added back. A large deferred tax reversal (the liability unwinding) reduces reported earnings-per-share but does not require cash, because the cash tax has already been paid.

Reversal and Permanent vs. Temporary Differences

A deferred tax balance is “temporary” because it eventually reverses. When it does, the gap between book and tax income closes. If a company depreciates an asset over 7 years under GAAP and 5 years under tax, the deferred tax liability is fully reversed in year 7, when the asset is fully written off under both sets of rules.

Some differences are “permanent.” A company that receives a tax-exempt dividend, or pays a non-deductible fine, has a gap that never reverses. Permanent differences do not create deferred tax assets or liabilities; instead, they affect the effective tax rate (the ratio of actual tax expense to book income).

See also